
A Loom user who can read sessions in an agent's group can read another user's prompts and answers from logs, traces, and evaluation exchange. Opening the session itself is still forbidden. v1.9.0 and v1.10.3. Medium 6.5.
A person in the same group as an agent, with permission to read sessions, can open another person's prompts and answers in the logs, the traces, and the evaluation exchange. Asking for the session itself is still forbidden.
Another group's agent stays forbidden. This is not a cross-group read.
Class: Missing per-session owner check on conversation text
Reach: Remote. session:read and agent:read in the agent's loom:group. The lab caller is a normal user in that group, not an admin of the tenant.
Loom v1.9.0 a3050669 and v1.10.3 cc10ab0
| ID | no CVE yet |
| Class | Same-group session-owner bypass on logs, traces, and eval exchange |
| Reach | Remote, in-group t-user |
| CWE | CWE-639 |
| CVSS | Medium: 6.5 CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:N/A:N |
| Product | awslabs/loom |
| Affected | v1.9.0 a3050669f5b4c83210a44ed4346f17e01641e82f and v1.10.3 cc10ab08573087fa12154f7c8181ffcd985fea88 |
| Auth | g-users-* matching the agent tag |
| License | GNU Affero GPL v3.0 |
| Lab | loopback Docker on v1.9.0. v1.10.3 was a source check. |
| Privilege | Method / sink | Impact | Lab-proven or inferred |
|---|---|---|---|
| Read their own session | GET /api/agents/{id}/sessions/{sid} as the owner | Recon of their own row | Lab-proven. Alice 200. |
| Be refused the other person's session | the same GET as a different user | Closed | Lab-proven. Bob 403. |
| Read that person's prompt and answer in runtime logs | GET .../sessions/{sid}/logs | Confidentiality | Lab-proven. Bob logs 200, witness in the body. |
| Read span input and output | GET .../traces/{tid} | Confidentiality | Lab-proven. Traces 200, witness present. |
Read prompt and answer from an evaluation | GET /api/agents/{id}/evaluations/traces/{tid}/exchange | Confidentiality | Lab-proven. Exchange 200. Same missing owner check, not a second bug. agent:read on the shipped group map already comes with session:read. |
Stays closed
| Axis | Method / sink | Why it is closed |
|---|---|---|
| Confidentiality | Another group's agent | Charlie's log read was 403 |
| Confidentiality | A caller-picked log group name | Vended log groups stay on the allowlist |
| Confidentiality | Session body for a non-owner | assert_session_readable |
| Confidentiality | An in-group admin reading transcripts | Intended. t-admin for that tag may read. |
Session GET grew an owner check. The CloudWatch readers that return the same conversation call get_agent_or_404 and then fetch the log stream. _resolve_agent_and_log_group never calls assert_session_readable. The evaluation exchange was already on agent:read in v1.9.0 and still is.
I ran the container on v1.9.0. On v1.10.3 the resolver is the same shape.
python3 loom-logs-owner-Abraxas-Labs.py
SUCCESS LOOM-190-LOGS-OWNER alice-session=200 bob-session=403 logs=200 logs-has-witness=yes charlie-logs=403 exchange=200 exchange-has-witness=yes traces=200 traces-has-witness=yes LOOM-190-LOGS-OWNER-WITNESS
Call assert_session_readable from the log, trace, and evaluation-exchange handlers before the body is read. Group membership is the wrong grain for another person's prompt.
cc10ab08573087fa12154f7c8181ffcd985fea88logs.py _resolve_agent_and_log_groupGNU Affero GPL v3.0. See LICENSE. Loopback lab only. No warranty.
Abraxas Labs [email protected]